Iowa State’s Bates Goes Bye-Bye

(AP photo by Charlie Niebergall of then-Iowa State football player Phillip Bates and his fellow quarterback, Austen Arnaud)

Thursday, it was announced that sophomore quarterback Phillip Bates is leaving Iowa State’s football program.

Bates had a huge play (as a receiver) against Iowa in ISU’s win over the Hawkeyes in 2007, and was certainly a quarterback of promise. But he was No. 2 at his position, to the constantly improving Austen Arnaud, who took every snap in the Cyclones’ 35-33 loss to Kansas last Saturday.

Bates had no comment. None is needed. Another player wanted to be The Man. Another player didn’t get to be The Man as soon as he would have liked. So another player has transferred. It’s an instant-gratification society, is it not?

This goes on everywhere. Some players are led to believe they’ll get what they want and quickly when they cast their lot with a school. Others make their own assumptions. Then there are those who commit to a school, accept that they’re in constant competition for playing time, and use that to motivate them instead of seeking greener pastures elsewhere.

We see players leave for more playing time at every school in every sport. It’s human nature to want to maximize your opportunities. And sometimes a place just doesn’t turn out to be the right one. But this is unfortunate. Bates leaves the Cyclones without a No. 2 quarterback of any experience at all. If Arnaud gets hurt Saturday or anytime this season, his team is stuck.

Bates could have seen this season through. Maybe something good would have happened because of it.

After last week’s Iowa-Michigan State game, a fellow sportswriter told me Hawkeyes junior running back Shonn Greene was gone after this season to the NFL, a rent-a-player.

“They all are,” I replied. And they are. Sometimes the coaches don’t do right by the players. And sometimes it’s the other way around.


3 responses to “Iowa State’s Bates Goes Bye-Bye

  1. maybe he didn’t like jersey no. 7

  2. Can you blame Shonn? Like the rest of us, he isn’t getting any younger.

    Hopefully, he listens to KF and makes the right call based on what he tells him about his chances.

  3. “What Goes Around Comes Around”
    The answer to the question is simple. These young men go off to college to get an education and while getting their education they play the sport that they love and cherish as kids with the hope of making it to the elite few (NFL) and when that dream of playing is not showing any possibilities of becoming a reality their hearts are crushed. I don’t see any reason why a highly recruited played such as Phil Bates would sit around for one year not to mention four years watching someone else be the star in their life long dream. It is a mutual agreement and he has every right to move on and pursue his dream. I would like to know why you would have two star quarterbacks graduating the same year on the same team. That was selfish on the coaches’ behalf. I am sure they knew that both players had high expectations to play and not be observers. I think that he should have been informed prior to the season starting that he would be playing the role as a back-up in order for him to make an effective decision rather to stay or go and not half way through the season, leaving him limited option. I wish all the best for you Phil.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s