Off You Go, Mariotti


Jay Mariotti has been the most famous sportswriter in the Midwest for the last decade. The nation knows him because of his television work on ESPN. Chicago knows him as a shrill, the-sky-is-falling, everyone-is-stupid guy who seemed to write page-long columns eight days a week for the Sun-Times.

Talk to any Chicago sportswriter, it seems, and you’ll get a disparaging comment or 50 about Mariotti. A friend of mine who works there has nothing good to say about him, and that person is what I would call very positive in general.

Mariotti quit the paper this week in a huff about something or another, and basically declared his paper and newspapers in general dead. Which gives me hope they’re very much alive.

I’ve had two experiences with Mariotti, one directly and one not. The direct one was more pleasant, even though it put my health in jeopardy.

Iowa State was playing in the NCAA men’s basketball tourney in Auburn Hills, Mich., in 1997, and there was an ice storm. I could have and should have waited for a shuttle back to the media hotel in Troy, several miles down the freeway, but took up Mariotti and another sportswriter on their offer to ride with them.

The other writer, whose name I cannot recall, drove. I didn’t envy him, because not only did he battle the slick road, Mariotti talked animatedly the entire ride and seemed oblivious to the danger we were in. We got to our destination safely, though we had quite the skid in the hotel parking lot. The conversation was friendly and interesting, and I enjoyed it.

The second episode … not so good. In the spring of 1997, I covered a Cedar Valley Cyclone Club banquet in downtown Cedar Rapids. It was a full year before Tim Floyd took the Chicago Bulls’ coaching job, but Bulls General Manager Jerry Krause had let it be known that he had his eye on Floyd to replace Phil Jackson one day.

Here’s what I wrote from that banquet for the Gazette:

McCarney said he spoke to the police chiefs of Ames and Chicago, claiming Ames officers have fired one bullet in 25 years while Chicago officers fire one every 25 seconds.

“Chicago’s a dangerous, dangerous place for your daughter to graduate high school, Beverly,” McCarney told Floyd’s wife.


Here’s what Mariotti wrote in the Sun-Times on July 20, 1998, as it appeared Floyd was going to become the Bulls’ coach:

They’ve tried everything to keep Tim Floyd at Iowa State, even gallows humor. At a Cyclone Club banquet, football coach Dan McCarney kidded Floyd that he had talked to police chiefs in Ames and Chicago and had some numbing crime statistics to report.

In Ames, he said, officers have fired one bullet in 25 years.

In Chicago, he said, officers fire one bullet every 25 seconds.

“Chicago’s a dangerous, dangerous place for your daughter to graduate high school, Beverly,” McCarney told Floyd‘s wife.


Gosh, that looked familiar to me. For the life of me, I didn’t remember Mariotti being at that Cyclone Club banquet. But he must have been, since he heard the exact same thing I did. Or else maybe, just maybe, he swiped that stuff without attributing it to where he found it.

But at least it’s nice to know you’re getting read, even if it is through someone else’s byline.

By the way, the Sun-Times still has Rick Telander and Greg Couch writing columns, and they are two of the best in the business.


3 responses to “Off You Go, Mariotti

  1. Let me preface this by saying I’m certainly no fan of Mariotti or his work. I’ve always thought he was a hack. But I’ve been thinking about your post and was wondering if what he did was plagiarism. Quotes are quotes and need to be reported as such.

    Don’t get me wrong. I’m not condoning what Mariotti did as right. But, I don’t think it was plagiarism. Certainly it was lazy reporting (assuming he was not at the event to hear the quotes first hand).

    I guess it was probably more unethical than anything else.

  2. It wasn’t my intention to categorize it as plagiarism, nor would I do so.

    I just didn’t like it because I put the time in at the event and wrote it, and he used it without any suggestion it came from The Gazette.

    Maybe we in newspapers do this a lot, I don’t know. Maybe this is small-minded nitpicking on my part. That’s a distinct possibility.

  3. I know you weren’t claiming plagiarism. But, you have have a right to be peeved when someone with a higher national profile at a larger paper benefits at the expense of “the little guy”.

    Either way, keep up the good work. I greatly enjoy your writing both in print on on here. While I don’t always agree with you (but I do appreciate the cynicism, especially since DuPree retired), you at least make me think.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s